The Australian Taxation Office is fighting from a position of ignorance when it comes to the whole trader versus investor question. They are interested in protecting the revenue of the state first & foremost and will ignore logic in order to tax the common man unfairly.
As a result of the GFC, many traders have sustained significant losses. The ATO' s strategy is to paint the trader as a speculator or Investor in order to force the trader into a situation where the trader has to report their activity on capital account thereby quarantining the capital losses. This action prevents the trader from offsetting their capital loss with their other income resulting in a much higher tax liability.
Anyway, here is my take on the whole share trader vs. Investor question and results from a dispute that I'm currently fighting on behalf of a trader client who suffered a horrendous $1,000,000 trading loss.
Here is my logic response to the Australian Tax Office's forced tax assessment on my client -
You mighty sir, should come down from your ivory tower and learn the hard way about the marketplace. You might postulate pompously about this place of the common man while your bloodsucking bureaucracy is funded off the backs off the merchant & the labourer but you must experience the 'tooth & claw' of the marketplace to really appreciate what trade means.
You use the word speculation in your letter. Here is the Wikipedia, (Our Common Human Consensus) Meaning of Speculation -
In finance, speculation is a financial action that does not promise safety of the initial investment along with the return on the principal sum
For all intents & purposes neither trading NOR investing can ever hope to promise safety of the initial investment. Ask your banking cronies who brought us the GFC!
Speculation has nothing to do with the question, was Mrs Brown buying & selling shares on capital account or on revenue account or was she a trader or an investor?
Though if you insist on using the term do please note the definition at this major dictionary site - http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/speculation - speculation is -
engagement in business transactions involving considerable risk but offering the chance of large gains, esp. trading in commodities, stocks, etc., in the hope of profit from changes in the market price.
The Nature of trading vs. Investing
Share Trading/ Revenue Account
Trading takes place when an entity enters a marketplace with the intention of participation that will lead to profit. Thus a trader must buy & sell.
A share trading marketplace in the strictest sense of the word, is a signalling system that allows for a trader to realise an arbitrage opportunity on the sale of a share or security. In a true marketplace & not in a duopoly or oligopoly, the arbitrage is always the difference in the market knowledge between buyer & seller / vendor & purchaser.
A TRADER is less concerned with the real value of the underlying asset as defined by increase or decrease in Net Present Value than with PERCIEVED value as reflected by the price of the security in the market place.
Mrs Brown relied on her husband Mr Brown to act as her agent and participate in the share market on her behalf. Mr Brown relied on research that he believed would provide him with arbitrage knowledge.
Hallmarks of a trader -
- Greater interest in market price of the security rather than underlying value of the asset
- Seeking out & using arbitrage knowledge
- Use of pattern based trading systems or paying for information from analysts who are perceived to have KNOWLEDGE or doing research
Mr Brown, agent of Mrs Brown exhibits a pattern of paying for what he believed was arbitrage information. He gets minimal broker buys on one account & then he REPLICATES what he believes is valuable unique MARKET knowledge with a LOWER COST market platform. This is the SYSTEM he uses. REGULAR TRADERS generally develop a PATTERN or a SYSTEM.
Traders use MARKET KNOWLEDGE & CAPITAL and will usually develop a SYSTEM.
Investment/Capital Account
Hallmarks of an investor -
- Investors look to secure real change in value of the investment that requires TIME.
- The pattern of an investor is typically a buy & hold strategy. Warren Buffet is a perfect example, often holding securities or stocks through high & low market prices over decades.
- Investors look for their investment to pay a cash return or dividend.
Minimum requirements for conducting a business -
While the Australian Taxation Office likes to RIG the SYSTEM by playing the ?business by degree? card, let us consider what 'business' really means.
What does Wikipedia say about what a business is - However, the exact definition of business, like much else in the philosophy of business, is a matter of debate and complexity of meanings.
Well let us at least explore minimal constraints for defining a business.
1. A market place where a buy/sell transaction can transpire. By default an ability to buy must automatically suggest an ability to sell.
2. Access to capital that can fund the purchase of stock item/s that can be sold in a marketplace. (Even a single saleable item of the lowest common monetary denominator should suffice). Shall we say $.0 ad infinitum to a final decimal of 1?
3. Ability to communicate one's intent in the marketplace, either to buy or to sell.
A business does not require frequency of trading or a business plan to be a business. Ask the one eyed man in the desert around Alice Springs with the last glass of water on the planet, bought by him from the Australian market today, as to how much PROFIT he would be able to collect should he be presented with the heads of the Australian banks, passwords in hand & access to a payment gateway & trading platform after 1/366 years in the said desert without water.
Indicators of Australian Taxation Office Understanding in relation to Capital Account
Capital Gains discount is ONLY available on Assets held > 12 months! This reflects tacit understanding that investors require TIME & CAPITAL in order to be permitted by law to reflect their market activity on CAPITAL ACCOUNT.
Mrs Brown leveraged knowledge & capital NOT time & capital. Unfortunately the knowledge was faulty (as knowledge often is) and Mrs Brown sustained a TRADING LOSS.
ae3265b9-ae71-483a-9a4b-b29b96f1db65|1|5.0